Your Knee Respectfully Invites You to a Healthier Life
As he started the 10th hole, the limp arrived like a rising ocean tide. At first, barely visible, the over weight man in his mid-40's trudged over the fairway carrying his steel-shafted Callaway clubs. But, with each passing hole, his walking speed slowed as his body tilted in an uneven rhythm right and left.
"Hey, Jim - wanna ride? Got plenty of room," shouted Jim's golfing buddy Rob.
"Nahh...thanks. Need the exercise," yelled Jim as he slapped a golf shirt stretched to its limit over a jiggling belly. "My doctor says I need to lose some weight! No kiddin'!"
By the 15th hole, Jim's knee was swollen. It was stiff, and ached. He called to Rob, "Hey, Rob! I'll take ya' up on that lift!". He climbed into the golf cart and rubbed his right knee. "Ahh...man...this hurts...oughta' quit, I guess...just about done..." rumbled through Jim's mind.
Jim finished the round, gulped down two Miller Lite beers with his buddy Rob, and then headed home. His knee seemed a little better.
He never thought about it again until two weeks later when he played another round. He made it four holes before he needed a ride. The following day, Jim called his doctor's office and made an appointment.
"Well, Jim, you've got osteoarthritis and the way I see it is you've got a couple of choices. First, you'll need to take these anti-inflammatories for about a month. Your knee's inflamed. Then, if you want to play golf, you'll have to ride. But, what you really need to do is to lose some weight - like about 30 pounds," said his doctor.
"Yeah...I know..but..I guess.. I need some kinda' exercise, right?" asked Jim.
"Right. You'll need to change your diet and you'll need to exercise more," replied his doctor.
Jim sat slumped on the edge of the exam table, looking down at the floor. "Uhhh..well...I don't know how that's gonna work, Doc. I mean, I..just..," and Jim's doctor interrupted him. "Jim, I've got to get to another patient right now but try a personal trainer or maybe a physical therapist. Here - I'll write you a script for some physical therapy. They'll be able to figure it out," and in a nano second Jim's doctor was gone.
How do you exercise hard enough and long enough to lose weight when something as simple as walking hurts?
No question Jim needs to change his diet, but without adding cardiovascular training and muscle training to ramp up his caloric burn, he won't lose an ounce of weight. If he goes to the gym and tries either of these exercise options, his knee will hurt.
Some people believe that strengthening the muscles around the knee is Jim's answer for his stiff, achy joint but the physical forces required to truly fatigue the muscles will be greater than the joint can withstand. The result is a sore knee with little to no muscular fatigue. After a few rounds of this kind of exercise, Jim will quit, maybe play golf but settle for riding in a cart, fail to lose weight, and compromise his long term health and happiness.
The answer for Jim's knee pain is is to strengthen the joint cartilage first then strengthen the muscles. If Jim does this, he stands a good chance of being able to lose weight and reclaim his health.
You're probably wondering, "How do I do that?" I've written about this topic before but, in a nutshell, your body adapts to physical stress in very specific ways. Joint cartilage needs a different form of exercise than muscles; a different prescription. The unique intensity, frequency, and duration of the exercises for joint cartilage create a strengthening effect in the same way that lifting weights creates a stronger muscle. Using a muscle training prescription on a joint cartilage problem is like taking a drug that lowers your cholesterol and expecting it to lower your anxiety. The solution needs to match the problem.
People who have knee osteoarthritis like Jim can do something about it if they act quickly. The early signs of joint trouble include stiffness and aching that comes and goes and sometimes a sense of fullness in your knee. Ignoring the symptoms allows the disease to take hold, erode your cartilage and then begin eroding your bone. You then may end up in surgery yet still have all of the health issues associated with being over weight.
If you're like Jim, your knee pain is an invitation to a healthier life. You need to RSVP.
Will you?
Doug Kelsey


